Polo Paolo Il Gelato Italiano 426 Main St, East Haven, CT06512 Polo Paolo Il Gelato Italiano is a custom gelato shop that imports its products, such as the menu boards and display…More cases, from Italy. The gelato handcrafted here is served on a popsicle stick, with options of 40 flavors. After selecting which bar they want, customers then dip it into milk chocolate, dark chocolate, white chocolate, pistachio cream, lemon, strawberry or caramel. After that, toppings -- almonds, pistachios, cookies, coconut, dark chocolate and hazelnuts -- are chosen and sprinkled on top. The new business plans to expand its menu to include coffee, espresso, smoothies, shakes and grilled cheese.